San Antonio Business Daily
Privatization Knowledge Base
privatization? what are the pros and cons of privatization and what would it do to tax payers?
Privatization?? Alot of talk of the "BENIFITS" of privatizing aspects of government(social security)-Why no mention of privitizing the MILITARY????
What is the privatization of probation and parole services? What are three arguments in support of Privatization What are three arguments in opposition to Privatization What is the privatization of probation and parole services? Another ethical issue is whether states should privatize probation and parole services or continue to keep them public. Proponents of privatization argue that there are several benefits of turning over various governmental services to private corporations. One alleged benefit is the reduction of operating costs. Proponents claim that private enterprise can do things more efficiently and less expensively than the government. Government operation is equated with waste and inefficiency. Some of this is attributed to the civil service system, which guarantees job tenure except in extreme circumstances when jobs are abolished. Civil service workers are not under the same pressures as workers in private industry, who must consistently show a profit. Opponents of privatization argue that government agencies can be efficient and effective. According to this perspective, government offices can adopt efficiency and effectiveness enhancing strategies just as do privately run agencies. Perhaps the main argument against privatization is whether it is appropriate for the government to turn over functions as basic as the correctional supervision of offenders to private businesses. Many question whether the symbolic task of punishing offenders should be handed over to workers who wear uniforms that say “Brand X Corrections” rather than the “State of ___” (American Bar Association, 1986). the most dramatic example of this would be for render the symbolism of the state executing an offender? Less dramatically, is it right for the state to contract out prison operations that involve the deprivation of liberty and serious disciplinary measures such as solitary confinement? Set against this context, is it ethical to allow a private company to operate a probation or parole operation that involves the very important decision of whether to allow an offender to remain in the community or be revoked for a violation and sent to prison? Or does the deprivation of liberty involve a basic right that ought not to be relinquished by the government? Another concern with regard to privatization is whether the profit motive can debase corrections. For example, would private probation or parole agencies be under pressure to keep clients under supervision beyond an appropriate release time so as to keep caseloads and reimbursements high? Would private agencies try to pay their employees fair salaries, or would profit pressures work to minimize salaries and benefits for officers? Would private agencies try to cut services for offender (e.g., counseling, drug treatment) to a minimum? In the 19 century, the profit motive did operate to cause significant problems in many state prison systems. In one juvenile system, for example, boys would be kept under supervision longer than necessary because the contractor did not want to lose their productivity. A more recent example of the profit movitve perhaps having a negative effect occurred in Texas in 1997. Guards in a Texas jail were videotaped apparently shooting offenders with stun guns, kicking offenders in the groin, allowing dogs to bite the offenders, and making offenders crawl on their hands and knees. These guards were Texas jailers supervising Missouri offenders who had been sent to excess jail space in Texas because of over crowding in Missouri-at a charge of $40 per day per offender to the state of Missouri. This situation is sort of an in-between area between public and private enterprise, in which one state offers a service to another state for a profit. Arguably, the profit motive influenced Texas officials to be lax in their training and or supervision to the extent that this brutality occurred. One response to such problems is spelling out a private agency's responsibilities to offenders in a carefully devised contract and then monitoring the implementation of the contract. If state inspectors enforce the contract conditions, then problems can be prevented or quickly resolved. If a private agency does not resolve any problems, they are in violation of the contract and the agency can be dropped. Opponents of privatization argue that there is a problem with this argument. If the state wants to end a contract, there may not be another service provider willing and able to step in and take over the contracted service. At the very least, it would take some time for another company to be ready to provide the needed service. Still another problem with privatization is not private agencies can be overly selective of the clients they want to manage. Private agencies in corrections and in areas such as welfare have been criticized for picking the most capable clients. The criticism is that these individuals may have been able to succeed on probation or in getting off of public assistance with little or no h
What if the Republican Health Care solution was mandated privatization? How loud would the liberals howl? Could you imagine the scorn, ridicule and rage from the left, if Republicans even propose such a "privatized" solution to health care? Forcing the uninsured to purchase private insurance policies from FOR PROFIT corporations, or face the IRS? Is this like when Bush makes the Patriot act - liberals howl, but when Obama strengthens it, they cheer? I just don't get why liberals are embracing the mandated privatization of for profit health care What's next, the privatization of Social Security ?
What are the benefits of privatization in developing countries? How does it improve economic growth of a country. Why it is more advantageous to apply privatization in developing countries rather than developed countries. Can anyone explain in simple language, i am new in economics field.
What good can come from water privatization? I have been researching water privatization and I have found enough reasons to why privatization is a terrible idea (high costs, sub-par water conditions and lack of say from the community) but to be completely unbiased in understanding the situation I need some reasons of how privatization can possibly be positive for a community. Thanks for the answers!
What is the difference between Privatization and Part Privatization? I dont understand the difference... Is privatization when the government gives it all away or still has some of the business?
What are some examples of privatization today or in recent history? I'd like some examples of how privatization has benefited our society. The more impact they have the better!
What is the role and purpose of privatization? What is the role and purpose of privatization? Why is it so important to the prisons today? Why don't we just keep it state and federal ran and cut costs that way?
What the pros to Privatization in the health care system? School project. I'm working on a debate to introduce privatization in Canada. I need to know the pros. Thanks
Government Question! Is privatization a good method to reduce the size and cost of the federal bureaucracy? Please help!! the question says: "Is privatization a good method to reduce the size and cost of the federal bureaucracy? Why? Be sure to address how privatization would affect the democracy and equality in the country."
what do you think about quality of rakı after privatization? You know many kind of local raki emerged in the market in turkey in the past it was produced by the government. Do you think raki lost its quality a bit after privatization ? Note : Raki is a popular alcoholic drink.
the difference between the sale of public corporations and privatization.? Hello, I am a student studying Financial market and struggling to understand it. What is the difference between the sale of public corporations and privatization in terms of finance? Would you please make it clear? Thank you!!
Give some examples of how privatization has helped the economy? I am doing a paper on the benefits of privatization. What are some specific examples of privatization? (such as privatizing garbage pickup etc.) If you can, give when/where it happened, how much money was saved, and any benefit. Thanks
What are some images I could use for Privatization of Religion and 7 tendencies of individualism? I have to do a religion project, that involves making a collage. Any ideas for what i could use for either Privatization of Religion or 7 tendencies of individualism? Thanks
Trying to understand Privatization in the government? What exactly is privatization in the government I have to read two articles, the fox in the henhouse and downsizing the federal government, and do not understand what they're trying to stay or what exactly privatization is. HElp!
Do you think the privatization is a good option for you and the economy as a whole? Considering the state of social security and the growing challenges faced by the federal government, Do you think the privatization is a good option for you and the economy as a whole? How will privatization of social security positively effect your personal finances and the economy in a large extent? How can we solve the insolvency of social security.
What are your views on Water Privatization? What are your thoughts and feelings regarding water privatization? For? Against? Why? Pros? Cons? Anything you have to add on the subject.
Anyone got any solid examples, sources, or quotes pertaining to the privatization of space exploration? I'm trying to come up with a speech, and it has to do with the privatization of space exploration. I'm scrambling for anything right now, so if anyone has any sources, examples, quotes, or ideas that could be of assistance here, it would be greatly appreciated.
What do you think of the planned privatization of prisons in Arizona? The state of Arizona has plans to lease 9 out of 10 of its prisons to private companies. How do you feel about the privatization of an area that was once under public control? Do you feel like the potential for the prison system to be abused for profit is too large? http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/24/us/24prison.html
What if privatization of any health care services was forbidden by the law? What if privatization of any health care services was forbidden by the law? How would this affect businesses and their communities?
What are the advantages of water privatization? What are the advantages of water privatization?
How would privatization, deregulation, and removal of barriers to foreign direct investment affect the ...? How would privatization, deregulation, and removal of barriers to foreign direct investment affect the efficiency of business, new business formation, and the rate of economic growth in India during the post 1990 time period?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of privatization to the..? privatization of public industries 1. government 2. consumers 3. employees? where can i find more infos on these? thanks. i need points with elaboration and example. thanks.
What do you think about privatization of the educational system in this country? The educational system in this country is obivously in need of help, particuarly in some southern states. Generally speaking, we know that the private sector can provide better services than the government, so why are people so afraid of privatizing major areas, such as education?
Is privatization of the health sector desirable or should the government make efforts to improve this sector ? What are the future prospects for this sector, particularly in view of the rise in ‘medical tourism’?
Difference between social security privatization and turning 401ks into government run accounts? Since democrats were so against turning social security into government run individual retirement accounts (privatization), what is all this talk I hear about them thinking of turning 401ks and IRAs into government run individual retirement accounts? Maybe I'm misunderstanding something. Please explain.
Conservatives/libertarians - are you sure privatization of Social Security is the free market approach? It seems to me that if privatization - generally sold as a free market alternative to the existing system - would have passed, there would be intense pressure on government to reflate asset prices and/or compensate people who've "lost" lots of money. If memory serves, I think I read a libertarian perspective agreeing with this conclusion on the Mises Institute site a while back. However, I think it's still very much a minority position amongst libertarians and conservatives - could one of you enlighten me?
Is Obamacare just a privatization of Medicaid with middle class forced to pay high premiums to subsidize costs? Is that it in a nutshell? Are all private insurance companies now finger-puppets of the federal government with all rates, payouts, and coverage approved by the Secretary of Health and Human Services? Is it constitutional to destroy the middle class families' access to a free market-driven health insurance system? How does the federal government justify usurping control?
what is the different between deregulation and privatization? I mean to know the real differenece between deregulation and privatization as regard to economist view.
What is so bad about privatization of social security? I havbe heard it explained what it is and I don't see the problem with it. I like wuxxler's answer, especially the animal farm referance. The way social security is now wouldn't young people lose the most because of how people are living longer and so the can live for 20-30 years after they retire, meaning they live off the system for that long and allow less money for younger generations. Actually I am of the belief thewre there are no safe stocks yet I still think there is something else you can do if social security were privatized.
Can anyone provide some information about privatization of telecom in India? I need to know why it was privatized and what were the benefits and disadvantages and so on. Any website etc will be helpful.
has ATC saftey gone up since privatization in UK and canada? Since privatizing their towers, has safety improved?
Following the privatization of Social Security, will c0nservatards pursue privatization of oxygen? "In America, breathing oxygen is a privilege".
What are some recent examples of nationalization or privatization? I don't know where I can find some recent examples of those two.... :S If you don't have any examples, could you please tell me where you would find that information? And the examples have to be recent...so..blarh I have no clue where to search.. Thanks.
What's the difference between Bush's privatization of Social Security & Obama's privatizing of Social Medicine? Why is privatizing Social Security the worst thing Liberals have ever heard of but forcing the uninsured to purchase FOR PROFIT policies from PRIVATE INSURANCE COMPANIES is wonderful? I don't get it ?
What are your thoughts on Post modernity, plurality and privatization in secularization? I am not in this section very much but am I ask for thinkers please?
Would privatization and deregulation make a mixed market more or less economically productive? What are your thoughts? Please explain and if possible site sources.
What is Privatization of War? Which wars have been privatized? What is Privatization of War? Which wars have been privatized? What leads to privatization? What are the effects of privatization? What does society think of privatization? Any info on Blackwater? or Privateers?
Do you think the US' privatization of space travel is a positive step for the industry? If I'm not mistaken, the US government is retiring its fleet of spacecraft and will be relying on private companies, and other governments, to transport personnel to and from the ISS. Do you think this is a good thing for the future of space exploration?
What do you think of Social Security privatization? I disagree with the current federal administration on almost all issues except liberal gun rights. I gave the idea of privatization of Social Security as proposed by our president on creating accounts for young American citizens to invest in over three or more decades of active working life a serious thought. If one is financially independent by the virtue of pride, perseverance and hard work and have a big nest egg in retirement savings, obviously that person doesn't need to receive a pension. On the other hand, the majority of the people who have worked in active labor for three to five or six decades can always opt to receive the pension upon mandated age of retirement or verified disability to alleviate economic hardship. If laissez-faire economic policy (w/o govt intervention except stock fraud & abuse) apply w/ the new elective admin, should SS be done away with in gradual dissolution to reduce govt size or stay preserved, whole or partial with private investment account? To make my political view clear, I'm a registered Libertarian (green libertarian) and former Independent. I cast vote on any candidate of diverse political affiliations based on the appeal of honest campaign and character promoting progressive changes while striving to reduce government size. I'm a Jeffersonian type.
What is Privatization of War? Which wars have been Privatized? What is Privatization of War? Which wars have been privatized? What leads to privatization? What are the effects of privatization? What does society think of privatization? Any info on Blackwater? or Privateers?
How has the Bush philosophy of 'privatization' worked? Is this a way to become rich at taxpayer expense? Everything I read shows that privitization means shoddy products, contacts not completed or delivered, programs that dont work....because the people at the top of these programs are enriching themselves and not delivering the products or services they promised. What are your experiences? this may vary from state to state
Considering the current state of the economy is privatization of Social Security a good idea? How many would be invested in companies like Bear Sterns...or Carlyle or even Blackstone (all losing lots of money right now and BS sold for a measly 2.00 a share) ? If you are a supporter of privatization does the current state of the ecomony give you pause for concern? That should be "partial privatization"..oops. The largest slice of the Federal budget goes to Social Security, that's not including medicare and the new prescription drug plan.
The privatization of Medicare is the centerpiece of a new Republican deficit reduction? My question is: Do you support the cutting and privatizing of Medicare? Why or why not? Peace through blinding force, You are an idiot. You all can report me for that. It won't change the fact that she is an idiot.
If McCain would succeed in the privatization of schools ? Would our property taxes be less ? I mean public schools are funded for the most part by property taxes. If his plan is to get rid of public education by using military teachers in Charter schools, will MY taxes be less ?
Is it a good thing Bush's privatization of Social Security to stocks did not happen? All those retirement funds would have gone to AIG employee bonuses
Where can i find case studies especially related to privatization? Can anyone provide the websites or anything else??
What is a great opening statement in opposition to privatization of social security? I need help with it for a debate in class and the teacher is really tough :/ Please be as specific as possible! Thanks :)
For privatization programs to succeed, it is essential to? 1. declare the old state-owned enterprises bankrupt. 2. eliminate externalities in the industrial sector. 3. use tariffs to protect the enterprises from import competition. 4. cut the ties that bind the enterprises to the government bureaucracy.
Doesn't privatization of Government assets divert capital from necessary innovation? With climate change we have to invent a vastly different economy, with new technologies for most things from transport to housing. In Australia now, Government agreements with Tollway operators are now preventing the development of competing alternative road systems and public transport systems - and there are plenty of similar situations globally from tollways to fossil fuel power generation, communications systems, water, etc. Most contracts even guarantee private interests very high returns, with penalties at public cost. Isn't it time we took back responsibility and authority for the community utilities past generations created?
Is the government ineptitude that republicans point to as a rationalization for their privatization scams? a self fulfilling prophecy under republican regimes? I always thought that the reason they hate government was because they were so bad at governing. thanks 60's rad
What effect does the privatization of nationalized industries on national income and average price level? in the long run and short run?
Do you think the democrats would ever support privatization of public education since we know children suffer? under the current system or do the democrats care more about union support?
Why is that thousands of Chinese steel Workers oppose privatization and killed their boss? Is this another sign that the struggle of working class is spreading all over the World? http://www.enews.ma/china-steel-workers_i138305_2.html
Is the bailout of Fannie & Freddie proof privatization fails? Up until 1968, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were government-run and healthy. However, in 1968, both mortage lenders were privatized. Today, however, under private ownership, both lenders have collapsed, but will now, by an extraordinary decision by Treasury, be propped-up using untold billions of taxpayer-dollars. The private shareholders will therefore be bailed-out as if their investments never under any risk. Is this further proof that privatizing government-run financial enterprises simply creates a dis-incentive for the private owners to run these operations responsibly?
What are three arguments in support of Privatization/What are three arguments in opposition to Privatization? What are three arguments in support of Privatization What are three arguments in opposition to Privatization What is the privatization of probation and parole services? What are three arguments in support of Privatization What are three arguments in opposition to Privatization What is the privatization of probation and parole services? Another ethical issue is whether states should privatize probation and parole services or continue to keep them public. Proponents of privatization argue that there are several benefits of turning over various governmental services to private corporations. One alleged benefit is the reduction of operating costs. Proponents claim that private enterprise can do things more efficiently and less expensively than the government. Government operation is equated with waste and inefficiency. Some of this is attributed to the civil service system, which guarantees job tenure except in extreme circumstances when jobs are abolished. Civil service workers are not under the same pressures as workers in private industry, who must consistently show a profit. Opponents of privatization argue that government agencies can be efficient and effective. According to this perspective, government offices can adopt efficiency and effectiveness enhancing strategies just as do privately run agencies. Perhaps the main argument against privatization is whether it is appropriate for the government to turn over functions as basic as the correctional supervision of offenders to private businesses. Many question whether the symbolic task of punishing offenders should be handed over to workers who wear uniforms that say “Brand X Corrections” rather than the “State of ___” (American Bar Association, 1986). the most dramatic example of this would be for render the symbolism of the state executing an offender? Less dramatically, is it right for the state to contract out prison operations that involve the deprivation of liberty and serious disciplinary measures such as solitary confinement? Set against this context, is it ethical to allow a private company to operate a probation or parole operation that involves the very important decision of whether to allow an offender to remain in the community or be revoked for a violation and sent to prison? Or does the deprivation of liberty involve a basic right that ought not to be relinquished by the government? Another concern with regard to privatization is whether the profit motive can debase corrections. For example, would private probation or parole agencies be under pressure to keep clients under supervision beyond an appropriate release time so as to keep caseloads and reimbursements high? Would private agencies try to pay their employees fair salaries, or would profit pressures work to minimize salaries and benefits for officers? Would private agencies try to cut services for offender (e.g., counseling, drug treatment) to a minimum? In the 19 century, the profit motive did operate to cause significant problems in many state prison systems. In one juvenile system, for example, boys would be kept under supervision longer than necessary because the contractor did not want to lose their productivity. A more recent example of the profit movitve perhaps having a negative effect occurred in Texas in 1997. Guards in a Texas jail were videotaped apparently shooting offenders with stun guns, kicking offenders in the groin, allowing dogs to bite the offenders, and making offenders crawl on their hands and knees. These guards were Texas jailers supervising Missouri offenders who had been sent to excess jail space in Texas because of over crowding in Missouri-at a charge of $40 per day per offender to the state of Missouri. This situation is sort of an in-between area between public and private enterprise, in which one state offers a service to another state for a profit. Arguably, the profit motive influenced Texas officials to be lax in their training and or supervision to the extent that this brutality occurred. One response to such problems is spelling out a private agency's responsibilities to offenders in a carefully devised contract and then monitoring the implementation of the contract. If state inspectors enforce the contract conditions, then problems can be prevented or quickly resolved. If a private agency does not resolve any problems, they are in violation of the contract and the agency can be dropped. Opponents of privatization argue that there is a problem with this argument. If the state wants to end a contract, there may not be another service provider willing and able to step in and take over the contracted service. At the very least, it would take some time for another company to be ready to provide the needed service. Still another problem with privatization is not private agencies can be overly selective of the clients they want to manage. Private agencies in corrections and in areas such as welfare have been criticized for p
How many would support complete privatization of the military? They get better pay, better benefits, they have real medical insurance and if they get blown up the get real medical care instead of shafted with broken VA. They can have contracts around the world but in times of real necessity contracts are cancelled and they fight the war. I think this is vastly superior in all the ways mentioned but also they get ongoing training in real conflicts. Just a thought please post yours!!
Explain why the Government is so bad? people who support privatization? Isnt the govt just the people? of the people? elected to organize the group efficiently? Letting private profit hungry corps have control of everything creates the people themselves being abused. Isnt the govt the counterbalance for the elite abusing the people. Isnt the elite vs. the people the struggle of all nations of history? In privatization with little government, how do we police them?
can somebody tell me how to against Water Privatization? Water is an economic good that should NOT be treated as a commodity and bought, sold and traded accordingly. can u ppl give me some example for this topic? like why water should not be private to the ppl?
What piece(s) of federal legislation allow for the privatization of federal/state prisons? I'm trying to find which pieces of legislation allowed for or enabled the quick growth of private prisons. I can find legislation relating to the topic on the state level, but there is little I can find on the federal level.
How do stakeholders think of privatization of the public sector in an economy and what do they need?
How does privatization impact the functioning of government? Does it improve it or impede it? What impact does this have on personnel of agencies being privatized? Has any government function been privatized in your area? What was the result?
What is privatization in a company?, and what is IPO? i have to explain privitization or IPO of a company of my choice.. but i i amnto sure what either of those means. Does anybody know? THANK YOU
Will you point me toward well-respected, bonafide economists who oppose Social Security privatization? I am certain that I have read and heard commentaries by bonafide economists where they have railed against the Bush plan for privitization of Social Security, but now that I am specifically looking, I cannot find these materials. Can you (and will you) help?
Would privatization of national defense be a good idea? Hand over the military to a corporation with stockholders and watch it become streamlined, efficient, and profitable! No more taxes going to defending Iraq! And remember, Republicans are in favor of privatizing everything else, so please... no double-standards, ok?
Do you like the idea of privatization of postal service? How should the government select the new owner?
Do you think privatization of all military activities would be bad? Would this be positive or negative? Please military servicemen and woman express your views..OR ANYONE ha Hah i just wanted opinions and douchebag pool boy cant read a question properly.
What leaders and interest groups support Medicare privatization? I know that Medicare privatization is supported by George W. Bush and Heritage Foundation and those against it is the Medicare Rights Center. Is there any other interests groups or political leaders that support either of these?
Powered by Yahoo! Answers
Sitemap
© 2010 San Antonio Business Daily. All Rights Reserved.
San Antonio Business Daily is powered by kwikcontent.